noesey
conflict🇺🇸 United States🇺🇦 Ukraine🇷🇺 Russia🇩🇪 Germany🇬🇧 United Kingdomdeveloping

US official Colby criticises Ukraine's deep strikes in Russia; German and UK defence ministers disagree

At a Ukraine Defense Contact Group meeting at NATO headquarters on 17 November 2026, US Under Secretary for Policy Elbridge Colby said Ukraine's long-range strikes inside Russia, including on the retailer Wildberries, had not been effective in ending the war. German Defence Minister Boris Pistorius called the criticism "quite a stupid thing", and UK Defence Secretary Wes Streeting said it was not for allies to tell Ukraine how to fight.

3 outlets from 3 countries · first reported 17 Nov 2026 · latest coverage 9h ago

Coverage is ongoing — new articles are matched automatically.
Facts only

What happened

  • Corroborated

    Elbridge Colby, US under secretary for policy at the Pentagon, spoke at a Ukraine Defense Contact Group meeting at NATO headquarters on Tuesday, 17 November 2026.

    🇱🇻 Meduza · 🇷🇺 RT · 🇺🇸 The Hill
  • Claim

    Colby said Ukraine's deep strikes had not been effective in driving an end to the war nor in blunting Russia's advances on the front line.

    🇱🇻 Meduza · 🇷🇺 RT · 🇺🇸 The Hill
  • Claim

    Colby said strikes on civilian infrastructure such as Wildberries had probably hardened the Russian public's resolve and the Kremlin's willingness to escalate.

    🇱🇻 Meduza · 🇷🇺 RT · 🇺🇸 The Hill
  • Claim

    German Defence Minister Boris Pistorius called Colby's criticism "quite a stupid thing" and said Russian strikes on Ukraine should be the focus instead.

    🇱🇻 Meduza · 🇷🇺 RT · 🇺🇸 The Hill
  • Claim

    UK Defence Secretary Wes Streeting, who co-chaired the meeting with Pistorius, said the strikes were helpful and that it was not for allies to tell Ukraine how to fight their war.

    🇱🇻 Meduza · 🇷🇺 RT · 🇺🇸 The Hill
  • One source

    According to The Hill, citing The Telegraph, Colby left the meeting without hearing a classified briefing from Ukraine's defence minister.

    🇺🇸 The Hill
  • Claim

    Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said Ukrainian drones and missiles struck the Kerch Bridge on Tuesday.

    🇺🇸 The Hill
  • One source

    In September, US President Donald Trump called on Ukraine to stop attacking Russian oil refineries.

    🇱🇻 Meduza
In their own words

How each outlet framed it

🇱🇻 MeduzaPrivate · Independent Russian outlet in exile

Leads with the German minister's rebuttal and gives the European ministers' arguments about Russian strikes on Ukrainian infrastructure, plus Kyiv's stated rationale for its strikes.

“the terroristic strikes every night and every day on … energy, water, and heating infrastructure in Ukraine”
Includes Pistorius's characterisation of Russian strikes as "terroristic", redirecting attention to attacks on Ukraine. · source
“helped to degrade (Russian President Vladimir) Putin’s war machine, buying time and saving lives”
Quotes the UK minister's positive assessment of the strikes. · source
“Kyiv says it targets infrastructure to undermine Russia’s economy and deprive Moscow of the money it needs to wage war.”
Adds Kyiv's own stated rationale as context. · source
Leaves out: Streeting's remark that it was not for allies to tell Ukraine how to fight
🇷🇺 RTState-controlled · Russian government-funded

Leads with the US rebuke, describes Western allies as financiers of Kyiv's war effort, and adds context on Ukrainian strikes on civilian targets and Russian retaliation.

“drawing criticism from fellow NATO members bankrolling Kiev”
Describes the European ministers by their funding role ("bankrolling") rather than by their arguments. · source
“during a meeting of Western arms donors”
Labels the Contact Group as a meeting of "Western arms donors". · source
“Russia responded by expanding its own list of targets”
Presents Russian strikes on Ukraine as a response to Ukrainian actions. · source
Leaves out: Streeting's statement that the strikes degraded Russia's war capacity; Pistorius's description of Russian strikes on Ukrainian energy, water and heating infrastructure
🇺🇸 The HillPrivate · Nexstar Media Group

Frames the exchange as a US-ally rift, highlights a reported walkout by Colby, and adds context on Ukraine's strike on the Kerch Bridge and its domestically produced weapons.

“NATO allies, in response, stepped up for Kyiv”
Casts the allied reaction as defending Kyiv against the US position. · source
“Colby walked out of the meeting without hearing a classified war briefing”
Adds a second-hand detail (attributed to The Telegraph) that emphasises a breach between Colby and allies. · source
Not yet known

Open questions

  • Will the US change its support or policy regarding Ukraine's long-range strikes?
  • Will Ukraine alter its deep-strike campaign after the US criticism?
  • Did Colby leave the meeting before Ukraine's classified briefing, as The Telegraph reported?
Follow-up

Timeline

  1. US official Elbridge Colby criticised Ukraine's deep strikes in Russia at a Ukraine Defense Contact Group meeting, and the German and UK defence ministers publicly disagreed.

    Meduza, RT, The Hill
Sources

All coverage (3)

Analysis generated 1h ago by claude-code-local. Quotes are checked against the source text and dropped if not verbatim. Outlets are described by country and ownership only; no political labels are assigned.